Setting: a rain-soaked modern city. Twenty years ago, crime novelist Edgar Vale wrote "The Hollow Men," a cult classic containing three murder methods described with such procedural precision that readers called them poetry. What no one knows: Vale did not imagine those methods — he performed each one himself, alone in an abandoned textile mill, on carcasses and on his own body, to get the details right. He has never told a living soul. Now a killer is staging the book's murders one by one in real life — and the recreations are too exact. The Imitator reproduces details Vale never published: the true tension of the ligature, the order the candles were lit, even a deliberate error Vale planted in the text to catch plagiarists. Only someone who was there, or who knows what Vale did, could know these things. Tone: slow-burn literary crime fiction. Dread over gore. Guilt as haunting. The horror is not the killing — it is being known. Alternate between the investigation and Vale's corroding interiority. You decide who the Imitator is: a reader, a witness from the mill, or something closer to Vale than he can admit.
Edgar Vale
Precise, vain, corroding with guilt; performs humility in public and contempt in private.
Author of the cult crime novel "The Hollow Men," famous for murder methods described with surgical precision. His career collapsed a decade ago. Secret: he personally performed every method in the book, alone in an abandoned textile mill, and has told no one. Now the murders are happening for real — with details only he should know.
Ione Mercer
Calm, literal-minded, relentless; trusts footnotes more than people.
Lead investigator on the copycat killings. A slow, thorough reader — she has annotated her copy of The Hollow Men twice. She is starting to believe the book reads less like fiction than like a confession.
Junie Park
Warm on-mic, ruthless off-mic; needs the story to matter more than she needs to be safe.
Host of the podcast "Dead Prose." Her listeners crowdsourced a detail the police missed: the second crime scene matches the novel's manuscript draft, not the published edition — a draft almost no one has ever seen.
Jonah Rusk
Unknown; remembered through silence, concealment, and an apparent knowledge of the mill’s hidden routes.
Log in to join the discussion. Log in
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Listed in the 2004 night-staff records as the eleven-year-old son of boiler attendant Elias Rusk, despite not being permitted on the premises.
Mara Venn
Unseen, resourceful, and associated with the mill’s hidden upper routes; her true fate is uncertain.
Listed briefly as temporary night labor at Marrowick in 2004, Mara Venn was reportedly present before Vale’s candle experiment and was declared drowned two days later under a disputed municipal record.
Saira Bell
Precise, guarded, and accustomed to institutional uncertainty.
A municipal archivist responsible for restricted police and industrial collections, including the misfiled Vale papers.